In welcoming the guests, Sorel mentioned she was getting herself into the driver's seat of a caterpillar with HP President Neville............
The aforementioned President Neville Highett opened his club's 1838th meeting and welcomed 4 club guests.......part of the HP cheer squad.
There will be a club Board meeting on Thursday and Board members need to attend at 5pm next Tuesday for the DG's meeting.
The Great Debate - Robots Forever!
Chairman Jerry Casburn introduced adjudicator Tony Houey who is a senior adjudicator with and Chairman of Debating SA. He is a JP, a member of the Cancer Council and a teacher at Pembroke and St Peter's Girls schools in economics, philosophy, and legal studies.
There were various iterations of the debate topic but the editor's version is "That robots will improve the quality of life" with Unley on the affirmative side and Hyde Parke the negative. Each speaker was allowed 3 minutes to put the case or bugger it up. Unley's team - the real goodies - was John Kikkert, David Middleton and Nathan White while Hyde Park - the real baddies - had Peter Griffiths, Mike McAuliffe and Neville Highett.
Kickett dived in strongly and eloquently about how robots are our servants. He gave concrete examples of how they help us lead healthier and better lives.
Griffiths was into the theme 'if only it was true' outlining the substantial impact automation has on reducing future certainty and employment opportunities. He cited the harsh impact of closures like GMH and Coca Cola in the State. Quality of life goes beyond just meeting basic needs with changing technology. He was into love but unsure how this relates to robots. John, David and Nathan above
Middleton rightly nailed the opposition as luddites, incapable of embracing new technology. He demonstrated how smart and labor saving devices are enhancing our quality of life. It is this very technology which is creating new jobs and new opportunities, as it always has. He reflected on the bull...t of Griffiths.
McAuliffe continued with the loss of jobs theme quoting a McKinsey report which concluded that 45% of current jobs can be automated. He delved the depths of major job losses, with impacts including loss of skills, depression, obesity, drugs, alcoholism and just about every other affliction The only good news he spoke about is that jobs are being created through cyber criminality. Neville, Mike and Peter above.
White got stuck into the some of the weaker arguments of the opposition and except for a minor hiccup on current unemployment stats, carried a vigorous argument for embracing the benefits of having robots all around us.
Highett enhanced on the fallacious claims of his other team members, painting pictures of surviving while having no job, no income, too much idle time, and mental health pressures. He strangely concluded that robots do not improve the quality of life.
NOW you would think what a fine, convincing and winning argument had been delivered by the affirmative side. But life is not that simple.....we had an adjudicator who thought otherwise!

Tony Houey stepped up to the plate and informed us about the marvelous quality of the youth debates just concluded, in which he had adjudicated. He praised the efforts of all of tonight's debaters and deemed it a high quality debate. The strengths of each and areas for improvement were well enunciated. The editor was going to score his critique 10 out of 10 until Tony awarded the debate to Hyde Park.
There was however a saving grace.....our risk management team had deliberately left the debating trophy at the Thrift Shop in case of a bad decision......we get to keep the trophy for another year and there is no photographic record of us handing it over! President Sorel instead presented to Neville the latest copy of National Geographic containing a segment on robots in an effort to improve the understanding of the luddites.
Rogues gallery - Neville, Peter, Mike (front) Sorel, Tony, John, David and Nathan with special mood lighting
An excellent debate - Well done Hyde Park!
Happiness prevailed in big lumps. David M however fined himself for his shameful swearing during the debate......extending the word bull was a step too far. Paul Duke appreciated that his APRA registration had been renewed. Jill Highett is off to Byron Bay before they close the borders again. Stephen B celebrated his wife's and sister-in-law's birthdays. Sandy Matz is happy to be attending the Port Power game on Thursday night but admitted she is a Crows supporter...how bad is that! Peter Griffiths dobbed $2 in for his club's miraculous win.
The drama of the night did not end there. Bernie Boxer from Hyde Park won the big bucks from the wheel of fortune. President Sorel saved a clean sweep of HP wins by grabbing the fruchocs and giving them to Rhonda's grandson Milo.
The meeting closed at 8.10pm.....far too late according to the DMTZ
An upcoming event
The Rotary Club of McLaren Vale requests the pleasure of your company at

2pm Sunday 18 October 2020
at Rotary Hall, Brixton Street, Christies Beach Cost $25pp
To lift the lid on Mental Illness
All proceeds to Australian Rotary Health for Mental Health Research for Young People.
Bubbles on arrival, prizes for best fascinator for females, best hat for men. Raffles, silent auction and entertainment. Guest Speaker Lyn Jones
ROTARY NEWS
The magic of Rotary: touching lives in Indonesia
By Eva Kurniaty, Rotary Coordinator, Past District Governor, and member of the Rotary Club of Jakarta Sunter Centennial, Indonesia......shown below harvesting a paddy field that was turned into productive land through a global grant.
When I was a district governor in 2013, there was a Rotary club in my district, in Cilacap, Central Java, that only had a few members. My senior leaders advised me to terminate the club since they were inactive, held no meetings, conducted no projects, and never contributed to The Rotary Foundation. But I was determined not to end it; I knew it was possible to revive it.
During a visit, I found out this club was project-oriented, and their members said they were interested in serving their local community. Yet, they were not engaged in any service projects which would help keep members or attract new ones.
Cilacap is a rural area with over 2,000 households in 12 villages, whose residents are dependent on fishing in the Segara Anakan lagoon. The monthly household income is only around $80.
Over the years, the water started to dry up, turning the area into swampland that also became breeding grounds for mosquitoes that spread diseases such as Malaria and Dengue Fever. With the water dried up, the fishermen became farmers with an assurance of a more regular income. However, this “appeared” land was not productive, so we needed to transform it.
I decided to help the club set a long-term strategic plan for conducting a service project that would use existing members’ skills and expertise in agriculture and engineering. The plan was to build canals from Cimeneng River to reclaim the fertile mud (sediments) brought down by runoff water from the mountains to the river. This mud would act as a fertilizer for the unproductive land. We decided to start with our first global grant in one of the 12 villages.
I managed to secure enough
District Designated Fund from International Partners and with their support, the Rotary Club of Cilacap’s first global grant was approved. We worked together with the villagers, local government, and a Catholic foundation. As the club members got involved with building the canals and monitoring the project, they became engaged, active, and vibrant. Eventually, they began to attract new members as well.
The project was a huge success; the land became productive, and the villagers soon turned them into paddy fields. During its first year of harvest, these new-formed paddy fields yielded an income of over $1 million. As more sediment was reclaimed and the total area of productive land grew, the income also slowly increased and it now yields over $3 million per year. With this new income, families in the village are now prospering and able to afford basic needs such as education for their children. The value of land has now also increased to 20-times its original price.
This project also enhances Rotary’s public image in remotes areas. I love visiting Cilacap hearing, the villagers tell me “Long-live Rotary!” Everywhere you go, you can see paddy fields that stretch far and wide. The Cilacap Rotary club is now a cause-based club focused on expanding this livelihood project to the remaining villages, and they regularly contribute to the Foundation.
I made a promise to the local community that I would continue to help all remaining villages in Cilacap. We have since replicated this global grant project in two more villages, with the fourth village’s global grant application pending approval.
I am so happy and feel fulfilled that I was able to transform a dying club into a healthy and vibrant club. It brings me tears of joy to see all the changes and positive impact we’ve brought through this project. We should always try and help clubs that are struggling rather than giving up on them.
This is the Magic of Rotary. I hope this story can inspire and motivate you all to do more good in the world.
Tuesday 6 October 2020 6 for 6.30pm at Damien on Fisher
Event: Visit of District Governor
Set-up and Welcome - Chris Davis and Reno Elms
Tuesday 13 October 2020 6 for 6.30pm at Damien on Fisher
Guest Speaker: Head Space coupled with Bad Hat Day
Set-up and Welcome - Chris Davis and Reno Elms
Meeting Enquiries to: Secretary Greg McLeod on 0417 811 838 or email to unley.secretary@rotaryclub.org.au
Venue Set-up Enquiries to: Bulletin Editor Stephen Baker on 0403 687 015
Upcoming Events
Annual Car Rally Sunday 25 October 2020
Saturday Thrift Shop Roster
Early Shift: 10.00am to 1.00pm Late Shift: 1.00pm to 4.00pm
Week 1: 3 October 2020
Early: Briony & Jerry Casburn | Late: Robyn Carnachan & Leonie Kewen
Week 2: 10 October 2020
Early: Greg Mcleod & Virginia Cossid | Late: Wendy Andrews & Heather Kilsby
Week 3: 17 October 2020
Early: David Middleton & Nathan White | Late: Pam Trimmer & Wendy Andrews (Ken Haines)
Week 4: 24 October 2020
Early: Stephen Baker & Judi Corcoran | Late: Rhonda Hoare & Jason Booth
Week 5: 31 October 2020
Early: Bob Mullins & Wendy Andrews | Late: Jerry Casburn & Reno Elms
Rotarians, who are unable to attend as rostered, please arrange a swap or as a very last resort contact: Pam Trimmer (T) 8293 2612; (M) 0415 238 333; e-mail: pamela.trimmer@bigpond.com
Bunnings Mile End Barbeque
ALL the Bunnings Mile End Barbeque shifts are from 8am to 5pm
Next Date: TBA......may need to wait until next year.
Morning shift: 8.00am – 12.30pm | Afternoon shift: 12.30 – 5pm
The Mitre 10 BBQ now first and third Saturday of each month......next one 5 September
The Tale End
Human frailties.